10 super-melty sweet and savoury s’mores

American s’mores are a fun, sweet stack, best enjoyed around an open fire. As they’re made from only three simple ingredients – marshmallows, chocolate and sweet crackers – they’re ripe for reinvention. So that’s exactly what we did…

If you’re not fully au fait with American cuisine, chances are you’ve never heard of a s’more. This super-sacchrine, gastronomic curio is a short stack of marshmallow and chocolate, sandwiched by two graham crackers (a honey-based cracker sold in the US). And the name? Apparently it’s short for ‘some more’. This is one seriously Stateside portmanteau.  

As s’mores are traditionally toasted around an open fire, we started thinking of all the brilliant ways we could rework the blueprint for a good old fashioned British bonfire party (not to mention all those summertime camping trips). So our resident s’more fiend, cookery writer Chelsie, took to the kitchen to create 10 makeover sweet and savoury stacks.

10 new ways to serve s’mores

Cookie base classic

Classic cookie smoreThis three-ingredient s’more is as close to the true American version as we got. In lieu of graham crackers, Chelsie used chocolate chip cookies. If you wanted to go all out and make your own biscuits, our simple vintage chocolate chip cookies are ready in half an hour. But in the world of the s’more, a convenient off-the-shelf biscuit is a quite acceptable alternative.

Cookie base classic s’mores
 

Margherita s’mores

Margheria smoresWelcome to the world of savoury s’mores, where marshmallows give way to hunks of molten cheese. This pizza-inspired stack works on its own, or served beside a bowl of steaming autumnal soup, or perhaps an Italian-style minestrone. La vita bella indeed…

Margherita s’mores
 

Spicy salami s’mores

Spicy salamiWhile we’re on the subject of all things Italo-American, our salami s’more, with taleggio and olives, is another super-dippable sandwich of savoury flavours. Sturdy melba toasts make a good outer layer for s’mores thanks to their wide surface area, and if you want to eschew shop-bought, you can make your own using standard sliced bread.

Spicy salami s’mores


Cheese & bacon s’mores

Brie and baconIt’s back to the opposite side of the Atlantic for our bacon & Camembert s’mores, made with Ritz crackers and extra-melty Camembert cheese. We recommend them served with a generous dollop of cranberry sauce or fruity chutney on the side.

Cheese & bacon s’mores


Melty Ploughman’s s’mores

Ploughmans smoresA classic British dish in s’more form? All that’s left to add is a hunk of pork pie on the side. Cream crackers are another winning choice for s’mores, as they’re compact and can handle being subjected to the heat of a flaming bonfire.

Melty Ploughman’s s’mores


Salted caramel & peanut butter s’mores

Salted caramel smoresCould this be one of the greatest flavour combinations of all time? The waffle biscuits add an extra element of caramel goodness, plus we used all-American peanut butter cups for extra Stateside kudos.

Salted caramel & peanut butter s’mores


Banoffee s’mores

BanoffeeChocolate Hob Nobs sandwich the classic toffee and banana flavour combination in this ultra-sweet dessert s’more, with a traditional marshmallow melty layer added for good measure. Digestives or Rich Tea would work too. 

Banoffee s’mores


Lemon meringue s’mores

Lemon meringue smoreProving the flexibility of s’mores, this citrus version uses shortbread rounds as the outer layer. Any jam or spread could be used in place of curd, or try a different flavour - our homemade passion fruit curd would turn things a touch tropical.

Lemon meringue s’mores


Pumpkin pie s’mores

Pumpkin pieTwo classic American sweets become one in our autumnal pumpkin pie s’mores. Canned pumpkin puree is a great cheat’s ingredient, as it bypasses the need to deal with a whole, fresh gourd. You’ll find it in cans, usually imported from the US.

Pumpkin pie s’mores

Have you ever made American-style s’mores? If not, do our makeover versions tickle your pickle? Perhaps you think the original model is best left untouched – we’d love to hear your thoughts. We also have lots more recipes and guidance for 5th November frivolity in our Bonfire Night section.

Comments, questions and tips

Sign in or create your My Good Food account to join the discussion.
Be the first to comment...We'd love to hear how you got on with this recipe. Did you like it? Would you recommend others give it a try?
Be the first to ask a question about this recipe...Unsure about the cooking time or want to swap an ingredient? Ask us your questions and we’ll try and help you as soon as possible. Or if you want to offer a solution to another user’s question, feel free to get involved...
Be the first to suggest a tip for this recipe...Got your own twist on this recipe? Or do you have suggestions for possible swaps and additions? We’d love to hear your ideas.