This page was updated in August 2020.
Poor old cava. While champagne gets all the glamour and prosecco the popular vote, cava has something of an image problem. Figures released in 2017 showed that sales in Britain had dropped by 18%.
Most of this decline, to be fair, has taken place at the bottom end of the market, where cava producers don’t want to be. They are trying to move the category upmarket – £4.99 sparkling wine does not do much for cava’s reputation.
It’s not as if cava is cheap to make. Unlike prosecco, which gets its bubbles in a tank, cava is made in exactly the same way as champagne, by bottle fermentation.
It requires over a year to mature, so if it’s being sold at rock-bottom prices, corners have been cut or someone isn’t making any money.
Most cava comes from Catalonia, but some is also produced in Rioja and other parts of Spain. It’s usually made from a trio of Catalan grapes – macabeo, xarel-lo and parellada – though some champagne grapes are planted, too.
The traditional varieties have their virtues, but none of them has the easy grace of chardonnay or majesty of pinot noir. Cava can taste a little muted, with some vague apple flavours and a certain earthiness.
Or, that’s how it used to taste, anyway. Wines are now being made that seriously rival champagne, with prices to match. So, I thought it would be interesting to investigate whether this improving quality had reached the high street.
I tried a selection of widely available wines from supermarkets, wine merchants, online retailers and big brands. I tasted them all blind. There were a couple of standout wines, and a few surprises, both good and bad.
The ones I liked the most were unpretentious and fun, simple but not bland. In short, perfect wines for celebrating. They’re also a lot drier than most proseccos.
Next time you’re shopping for a decent sparkler, spend more than a tenner on a bottle of cava and I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised.
The best cava taste tested
Conde de Haro 2016
The most expensive wine was also the best. Made by rioja company Muga, it has a champagne-like nose, with a toasty, bready quality. There are very fine bubbles, some apple cider (but not scrumpy!) notes, and a floral honeysuckle quality.
Available from Harvey Nichols (£18.95)
M&S Prestige Cava NV
My favourite of the supermarket brands. It has some toasty, cakey notes on the nose, then on the palate there’s plenty of fruit, and it’s showing some toasty development with notes of coffee and yeast.
Available from M&S (£10 a bottle)
Freixenet Cordon Negro
A ubiquitous presence on the high street, I was impressed with this. It has a vibrant lemon sherbet smell, and then in the mouth it’s clean and fresh, with some roundness and toastiness on the finish.
Available from Ocado (£11), Tesco (£11) and Sainsbury’s (£11).
Contevedo Brut Gold NV
There are some really nice aroma of oranges and lemons; there’s clearly some quality fruit in here. Very light style on the palate, whistle-clean and fruity without much development. This is simple, racy and fun – I couldn’t believe it was so cheap.
Available from Aldi (£5.29)
Sainsbury’s Taste the Difference Cava 2014
This is made by cava giant Codorníu, and I preferred it to any of their branded wines. It smells a bit candied, like orange sweets, with good fresh fruit on the palate and plenty of yeasty, mature notes. Not bad at all.
Available from Sainsbury’s (£9)
Tesco Finest Vintage Cava 2015
It’s made by Segura Viudas, one the best producers in the region. Xarel-lo is quite a floral variety, and that really comes through with this wine. There’s also some tangy orange fruit and smoky, yeasty notes.
Available from Tesco (£9)
The best drinks taste tested
The best champagne
The best prosecco
The best rosé wine
The best rum
The best gin
The best non-alcoholic drinks
The best vodka
The best tequila
This review was last updated in August 2020. If you have any questions, suggestions for future reviews or spot anything that has changed in price or availability please get in touch at firstname.lastname@example.org.