Best rum - taste tested

Read our expert review and pick up a bottle of the best rum, from dark and spicy versions to versatile spirits that could be used for sipping or in cocktails.

Rum is less of a drink and more of a way of life, and its association with pirates, buccaneers and seafarers is no fable. A spirit made from a molasses or sugar cane base, it is sweet and highly drinkable. Dark, aged rum is perfect on its own, while white rum works its magic in classic cocktails such as the daiquiri. Here we pick 10 top bottles to sip or shake, all of which will rum-ble your tastebuds. 


Havana Club 3-year-old

Havana Club rum
If you only have one bottle of rum in your life, make it Havana Club 3-year-old. Cuban rum is deliberately designed to be lighter in style than some of the more robust Caribbean rums, and this makes it perfect for a classic daiquiri, or even a Cuba Libra… that’s rum and coke to you and I.

From around £18, available from most supermarkets. For more information visit the Havana Club website


Dark Matter Spiced Rum

Dark Matter rum
When you think of rum, it is usually palm trees and beaches that spring to mind, not the wilds of the Scottish highlands. Dark Matter, however, is produced at one of Scotland's rare rum distilleries, making a spiced version of the sweet spirit which is full-bodied with notes of clove. Try it in a hot chocolate

From around £25.00, find stockists on the Dark Matter website


Penny Blue Rum Batch 4

Penny Blue rum
Produced in Mauritius, Penny Blue is named after the ultra-rare stamp which features as the centrepiece to the island’s museum and was the first ever stamp issued outside of Great Britain. Matured in ex-Scotch whisky casks and ex-American Bourbon casks, it is produced in batches in conjunction with London’s Berry Brothers and Rudd, the oldest wine and spirits merchant in the world.

£40.00, buy from Berry Bros and Rudd


Cadenhead’s 11-year-old Barbadian Rum

Cadenheads
Rum can come from any number of places around the world, and the chaps at Cadenhead’s, Scotland’s oldest independent bottler of fine spirits, source rums from different distilleries across the globe. You'll find anything from a 10-year-old Nicaraguan offering through to a 1999 vintage from Guyana, but here we’re focusing on their 11-year-old Barbadian rum, which is sweet and delicious with a hint of oak and a wallop of vanilla. 

£35.50, buy from the Cadenhead’s website


Ableforth’s Rumbullion! Rum

Rumbullion
Chosen by the Ableforth Spirits Company, who also make the lip-smackingly good Bathtub Gin, Rumbullion! is a blend of rums from across the Caribbean. Aged in oak, this gives the rum a big flavour which works well in all cocktails, but especially with ginger beer for a Dark and Stormy. For the extra-thirsty, this also comes in a 1.5l magnum. 

From around £25.00. Read more and find stockists on the Ableforth's website


El Dorado 15 Year Old 

El Dorado

Probably the drinks industry’s rum of choice, El Dorado is produced in Guyana and has a remarkable quirk in production, as the distillery features wooden stills which are used for distillation at high temperatures. The age declared here is the youngest rum in the bottle, which has been matured in oak for extra flavour. This is one to sip.

From around £50.00. Read more on the Ed Dorado website


Wray & Nephew Overproof White Rum

Wray and Nephew
Keep a fire extinguisher on hand when you open this, for at 63% ABV, it’s potentially a hazard waiting to happen. With such a high strength comes an even punchier flavour and a small measure of this in your Hurricane cocktail will bring an immense peppery, liquorice spice to the drink. The original gunpowder in a bottle.  

From around £25. Read more about the brand here


Pusser’s Gunpowder Rum

Pusser's rum
Much in the same highly-flavoured category as Wray & Nephew, this 54.5% ABV rum also brings a rich, delicious, dark woody tone, alongside a balance of cinnamon and vanilla notes. The no-nonsense flavours in Pusser’s hark back to a time when the Royal Navy used to issue a daily rum ration. This continued until 31st July 1970, now known as ‘Black Tot Day’, when the tradition was, probably rather sensibly, discontinued. 

From around £33. Read more on the Pusser’s website


Plantation Stiggins Fancy Pineapple Rum

Plantation Pineapple
A revelation in the world of flavoured rums, this Caribbean rum was originally created by the Plantation cellar master as a highly limited edition treat for thirsty bartenders out in New Orleans, where it became an overnight sensation. Fortunately, this wonderfully sweet, aromatic pineapple-infused spirit is now available for the rest of us to enjoy and is perfect sipped over ice.  

From around £35. Read more on the Plantation Rum website


Ron Zacapa Centenario Sistema Solera 23 

Ron Zapaca
A multi-award winning, complex beast – and a rum which has arguably helped to spearhead the ‘premium sipping rum’ category. Ron Zacapa brings together a blend of different rums aged between six and 23 years old, giving a dry spice note alongside a decidedly mature oaky flavour. A rum that deserves plenty of your time to fully explore.  

From around £49.99. Read more on the Zapaca rum website

More on spirits... 

The best bourbon
The best artisan gins
The best traditional gins
10 spirits to buy to stay on-trend

Which rum do you drink? We'd love to hear your product suggestions. 

This review was last updated in February 2017. If you have any questions, suggestions for future reviews or spot anything that has changed in price or availability please get in touch at goodfoodwebsite@bbc.com. 

Comments, questions and tips

Sign in or create your My Good Food account to join the discussion.
Fi P
25th May, 2017
Disappointed with some of your choices. You missed out Diplomatico, Angostura...
southam17
26th Apr, 2017
Cuba Libra? Really? In a selection of the best rums by the BBC? To begin with, it's Libre (meaning "free," as in "Free Cuba"). Does it ring a bell?. And let's just leave it at that. For all that talk about professional journalism, trying to correct anglocentric worldviews is usually just a waste of time.
ewuska75's picture
ewuska75
10th Mar, 2017
You're missing Diplomatico - one of the best rums I've tried!
pattyenelextranjero
24th Feb, 2017
Venezuelan rum Pampero in its bottle with a leather cover is one of the best rums!
Be the first to ask a question about this recipe...Unsure about the cooking time or want to swap an ingredient? Ask us your questions and we’ll try and help you as soon as possible. Or if you want to offer a solution to another user’s question, feel free to get involved...
Be the first to suggest a tip for this recipe...Got your own twist on this recipe? Or do you have suggestions for possible swaps and additions? We’d love to hear your ideas.