All products were chosen independently by our editorial team. This review contains affiliate links and we may receive a commission for purchases made. Please read our affiliates FAQ page to find out more and read about how we write BBC Good Food reviews.


George Home Black 3-in-1 sandwich toaster

Pros: Versatile, effective, inexpensive
Cons: Toastie plates a little on the small side

Score: 4/5

Buy from George at Asda (£18)

Read our full review of the best sandwich toasters plus our pick of the best toasters.

More like this

You get an awful lot of kit for your money with this George Home sandwich maker. The machine itself is sturdy without being too heavy and the instructions are good, clear and detailed (it even explains how to change the fuse) though it’s a shame there weren't any recipes. It's an unflashy, average-sized machine that goes about its work effectively.

The sandwich toaster comes complete with three sets of interchangeable plates – one for toasties, a second for waffles, and a third flat one for grills.

We found that it pre-heated quickly in just three minutes and 20 seconds and it was clear when it was ready to cook as the green light came on. Our toastie, using standard supermarket bread which we buttered on both sides, was slightly too big for the plate so we had to put it across the second plate too.

The instructions said to allow two to four minutes for the sandwich to cook. When we checked it after two minutes, it was cooked if a little light for our liking. It was beautifully brown and crispy after three. The toasted sandwich was well sealed and the filling was melted.

Toastie on a plate with chutney on the side

To change the plates, you have to press locking pins (two for the top plate and two for the bottom) and then slot in the new ones. Removing the top plate was slightly tricky – the instructions helpfully explained you need to use your thumbs to push the pins while pulling the plate towards you with your little fingers. This was not the easiest of manoeuvres and it took a few attempts. The plates can be washed by hand or in the dishwasher.

We put the grill plate through its paces with a panini, which came out perfectly – dark, with a griddled appearance – after three minutes. This was an impressive result. The grill plates can be used for anything from burgers to vegetables and would be a good alternative to heating the whole grill, especially for one person.

Waffles take five to seven minutes to cook and we were happy with ours after six. The underside of the waffles cooked more evenly and browned more than the top and they stuck slightly to the plates, though they were easy enough to remove.


Multi-functional: Yes (sandwiches, grills and waffles)
Number of sandwiches: Two
Removable plates: Yes
Dishwasher proof: Yes
Recipe book: No
Height: 24cm
Width: 23cm
Depth: 11cm
Weight 1.4kg

Toastie maker reviews and recipes

Best sandwich toasters
Breville two slice sandwich toaster review
Von Shef 2 in 1 snack maker review
Cuisinart sandwich maker review
Tefal Snack Collection review
Cheese toastie recipe ideas
5 ways with grilled cheese sandwiches


This review was last updated in June 2019. If you have any questions, suggestions for future reviews or spot anything that has changed in price or availability, please get in touch at

Comments, questions and tips

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Choose the type of message you'd like to post