Best... Classic mince pie

Co-op mince pies

Co-op Truly Irresistible buttercrust mince pies


A traditional mince pie with lots of gooey filling. The pastry is very crisp while the mincemeat is fruity and refreshingly sharp - a guaranteed winner all round.

£2 for six, from Co-op

Best... Deluxe pie


Booths luxury mince pies

These delicious pies had a fantastic biscuity pastry and lovely orange flavours that came through the mincemeat. This pie was a real hit with our tasters.

More like this

£2.49 for six, from Booths

Best... Mini mince pie

M&S mince pies

M&S Collection handcrafted cranberry & clementine mince pies

If you're looking for a canapé-friendly pie or something special to give as a gift, these dinky pies are the product for you. The candied fruit, nut cluster and classic mini mince pie look great together.

£5 for six, from M&S

Best... Dessert

Tesco mince pies

Tesco Free From mince pies

With a fairly thick and cake-like pastry, these mince pies work well as a dessert with cream. They taste even better once heated up.

£2 for four, from Tesco

Best... Special diet pie

Booths mince pies

Booths gluten-free mince pies

These gluten-free pies had a really crisp pastry with a lovely sticky, rich filling. These pies are a good, chunky shape and will appeal to most tastes.

£2.29, from Booths


For more taste-tested products, equipment rundowns and buying advice, visit our review section, plus our Christmas kitchen contains everything you'll ever need for perfect festive feasting.

Comments, questions and tips

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Choose the type of message you'd like to post