The best saucepans on test

The BBC Good Food on-test team review everyday saucepans to discover which models are the best for heat distribution, easy cleaning and resilience.

Best... non-stick for all hobs

Circulon

Circulon Ultimum saucepans

Best bits: Durability, heat distribution and brilliant non-stick coating. 
Prices: £60 upwards

Comments: Whether you cook on gas or have an induction hob, you can’t fail to be impressed by this range of durable forged high density aluminium non-stick pans with stainless steel handles and lids. Not just smart to look at, they are dishwasher and oven safe up to 260C and can be used with metal utensils so you know your investment will last – they come with a lifetime guarantee to be extra sure. They have a thickened base for even heating and a patented 3-layer non-stick coating with the grooved design, which helps stop abrasions and enables you to cook with the minimum amount of fat. And this coating also ensures they are easy to clean by hand – we found the food washed off with hardly any effort. The stainless steel lid creates a great fit so very little steam escaped when boiling veg. We also liked their generous depth – a bonus if space on your hob is tight between rings as the 18cm pan that we tested had a capacity of 2.8 litres. 

Buy from Circulon
 

Best… for using in the microwave

Microwave saucepan

Kitchen Craft 900ml microwave saucepan

Best bits: A great tool for cutting cookery corners
Prices: Start around £6

Comments: Who says that you can't use pans in the microwave? If you like to grab the first thing you can to warm up baked beans or that handful of frozen peas I'm betting that this will become your new favourite gadget! It's made from stain-resistant plastic (so hopefully won’t go bright orange the first time you cook carrots in it) and has the handy design of dual pouring spouts, which is a bonus for left handers. The two side vents open to cook in the microwave and close to store food in the refrigerator. I bet that once you start using one of these you’ll be amazed at how much more efficiently your microwave works. It's my new favourite way to cook frozen spinach!

Find stockists on the Kitchen Craft website
 

Best… budget option

Wilko saucepans

Wilko five-piece stainless steel saucepan set

Best bits: Excellent value for money, plus bonus milk and sauté pans
Prices: £20

Comments: For the price you pay, you really can’t beat these pots. I use them frequently and they more than do the job. They do discolour slightly on a gas flame, but it's never a problem. They heat up extremely well and the long tapered design of the handles keeps them well away from any heat source. The set consists of three lidded pans, a milk pan, which heats soup in less that five minutes, and a sauté pan. They are very lightweight so if heaviness is an issue these would make a great buy.

Buy from Wilko


Best… for cooking on gas

Lakeland Flare pan

Lakeland Flare 20cm saucepan

Best bits: Brilliant heat distribution and can be used in the oven
Prices: £64.99

Comments: This cast aluminum pan has been developed specifically for gas hobs. The fins channel heat from the flame across the bottom, driving it up the sides of the pan, resulting in super-efficient heat distribution. This means the pan heats up significantly quicker on a gas hob so food cooks faster. I was skeptical but it really works. My spuds didn't boil over for a change and took about 10 minutes less to cook, plus I found it simmered food brilliantly. The inside of the non-stick pan is smooth so washing up isn't an issue and you can pop it in the oven up to 205C. Expensive but worth it.

Buy from Lakeland

 

Best... for sauces

Stellar milk pan

Stellar pan 6000 hard anodised 14cm milk pot

Best bits: Handy spout that's ideal for making sauces
Prices: £30

Comments: The design of this looks odd but it makes for an indispensable pan for sauces, soups and porridge. Made from anodised steel, it means that the excellent heat dispersion warms the walls of the pan as well as the base, plus making it suitable for all hobs too. With its deep sides, pouring lip, it’s simple to clean and the sculpted handle is surprisingly easy to grip. Although as it's metal, make sure you wear gloves as it does get hot.

Buy from Milly’s Kitchen Store

Reviewed by Sarah Sysum and Sara Buenfeld

Buyer's advice

Why buy?

We all need saucepans even if it's just to warm up baked beans. A good saucepan can do a multitude of jobs, from making mash to jam. So owning a few in different sizes is a kitchen essential.

What should I buy?

Firstly, take into account the amount of space you have. Large saucepans are great but require room; nesting sets, for example, will save you precious drawer space.

Take into account the hob you are using - some designs work better on specific hob types, plus you should consider the material of the pan. Aluminum is a good conductor of heat and a cheap alternative to copper, but it's soft and won't last as long as other metals. It's also a reactive metal, so when combined with some acid rich foods it may affect taste and colour. Anodised aluminum pans have been treated to stop the metal reacting with food while you cook.

Saucepan with caramel

What we looked for:

1. A pan that washes up well. I wanted a pan that, on the occasions when something did catch, a quick soak would bring it up like new.

2. A handle that's comfortable to hold. It's easy to forget how much you use a pan's handle when you're cooking. The handle should be comfy to hold, ideally with smooth edges that won't be slippery when your hands are wet.

3. The weight of the pan should be balanced. Heavy enough to feel stable on the hob so a spoon won't be enough to topple it over, but light enough to carry and pour comfortably. Pans obviously get heavier as they get bigger, but don't forget that the volume can also increase substantially so food will add a lot more weight.

This review was last updated in January 2017. If you have any questions, suggestions for future reviews or spot anything that has changed in price or availability please get in touch at goodfoodwebsite@bbc.com. 

Find more top kitchen kit by visiting our review section. We'd also like to hear your product suggestions - which saucepan do you use? 

Comments, questions and tips

Sign in or create your My Good Food account to join the discussion.
Be the first to comment...We'd love to hear how you got on with this recipe. Did you like it? Would you recommend others give it a try?
Be the first to ask a question about this recipe...Unsure about the cooking time or want to swap an ingredient? Ask us your questions and we’ll try and help you as soon as possible. Or if you want to offer a solution to another user’s question, feel free to get involved...
Be the first to suggest a tip for this recipe...Got your own twist on this recipe? Or do you have suggestions for possible swaps and additions? We’d love to hear your ideas.