We’ve picked products we think you’ll love and may earn commission from links on this page. Read about why you can trust BBC Good Food reviews.
KITCHENAID Artisan 5KMT4205BCA 4-Slice Toaster, best toasters

KitchenAid Artisan four-slice toaster review

The KitchenAid Artisan model is a sophisticated statement gadget that over-performs, but is expensive. Read our review of this investment toaster.

Our rating 
4.5 out of 5 star rating 4.5
Pros: Sleek and stylish, versatile functions, sophisticated technology
Cons: Large footprint, expensive

KitchenAid Artisan 5KMT4205 four-slice toaster summary

KitchenAid’s distinctive designs are statement investment appliances, built to catch the eye and last. Priced at £289, an investment is exactly what this toaster is.

Advertisement

The brand is known for its premium functionality, and this Artisan toaster is the most sophisticated model we’ve tested, packed with functions and accompanied by extras (like a sandwich rack) that add to the toaster’s versatility.

Available from:
KitchenAid (£289)
Harts of Stur (£288.98)

Read our full review of the best toasters to buy

First impressions

At 34.8 x 30.4 x 20.5cm, the Artisan toaster is a work surface hog, and would be best in kitchens with deep surfaces. Once unpacked, you can see why. Its curvy, die-cast metal construction protects two pairs of independently controlled toasting slots that are wide and deep enough to hold a variety of bread slices.

There are both button and slider controls, with diagrams that are clear enough for you to choose without having to flick through the large instruction manual. The slider indicates seven shade settings.

There’s an option to defrost and toast with the ‘frozen’ function, toast one half of your bagel while the other side warms, or make toasted sandwiches with the help of the sandwich rack accessory.

Toasting results

Loading your bread is an experience in itself. The slots are sensor-controlled and lower with a gentle ‘ping’, like you’d hear in an elevator. Once the bread is toasted, the toaster will automatically activate its keep-warm setting for up to 3 minutes if you don’t take it out within 45 seconds. We find this works well.

All the bread slices in the test are easily accommodated and brown evenly. Unlike the majority of toasters on the market, each setting under-toasts rather than overdoes the bread, meaning trial and error doesn’t easily result in burnt, wasted bread.

Level five produces evenly browned slices of large toastie bread, thickly cut artisan slices and a halved bagel. The specific bagel function’s 50 per cent reduction in temperature leaves the outer edges just nicely warmed. The fruit bread is best on level four, which results in browning without catching.

Is the KitchenAid Artisan 5KMT4205 four-slice toaster worth the money?

If you have money to spend on an investment toaster and the space for it to sit without completely dominating your kitchen, this model over-performs.

It’s a serious-looking gadget, but there’s a sense of whimsy to using it that’s enjoyable. For quality, the browning is even, and although it’s not particularly quick, the LED countdown timer makes it easy to see how patient you have to be.

Available from:
KitchenAid (£289)
Harts of Stur (£288.98)

KitchenAid Artisan toaster specifications:
Cancel button: yes
Browning settings: 7
Extra features: reheat, defrost, bagel function, automatic slice lift
Wattage: 2500w
Dimensions: 34.8 x 30.4 x 20.5cm
Weight: 7.5kg

Related reviews and recipes

Best toasters
Best sandwich toasters
Top 10 brunch gadgets
Best gluten-free bread
Avocado on toast recipes
How to make French toast

This review was last updated in February 2021. If you have any questions, suggestions for future reviews or spot anything that has changed in price or availability, please get in touch at goodfoodwebsite@immediate.co.uk. 

Advertisement

Do you have a toaster you love? We’d love to hear your product suggestions…