Millie's Cookies recipe
Member recipe

Millie's Cookies recipe

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
(276 ratings)

Member recipe by

Servings

Serves 1 - 12 Cookies

These delicious cookies are easy to cook and taste as good as the real Millies cookies, with a crisp outer layer and a gooey centre these treats are best eaten warm but last well...if they last that long!!!

This recipe has been submitted by the Good Food community. Sign in or create a My Good Food account to upload your own recipe creations. Please note that all recipes will be moderated but they are not tested in the Good Food kitchen.
Save to My Good Food
Please sign in or register to save recipes.

Ingredients

  • 125g butter, softened
  • 100g light brown soft sugar
  • 125g caster sugar
  • 1 egg, lightly beaten
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 225g self-raising flour
  • ½ tsp salt
  • 200g chocolate chips

Method

    1. Preheat the oven to 180°C, gas mark 4
    2. Cream butter and sugars, once creamed, combine in the egg and vanilla.
    3. Sift in the flour and salt, then the chocolate chips.
    4. Roll into walnut size balls, for a more homemade look, or roll into a long, thick sausage shape and slice to make neater looking cookies.
    5. Place on ungreased baking paper. If you want to have the real Millies experience then bake for just 7 minutes, till the cookies are just setting - the cookies will be really doughy and delicious. Otherwise cook for 10 minutes until just golden round the edges.
    6. Take out of the oven and leave to harden for a minute before transferring to a wire cooling rack. These are great warm, and they also store well, if they don't all get eaten straight away!

Comments, questions and tips

Sign in or create your My Good Food account to join the discussion.
Wendy5
11th Jul, 2018
5.05
Amazing! Loved it! So gooey with a slight crunch on the outside mmmmm
Preciousgem
26th Jun, 2018
5.05
Made this as a giant cookie (in a pizza tray lined with baking paper to cover holes) and iced it for my boyfriends birthday. He was surprised how nice it was! I reduced the sugar to 80g brown and 100g white but think I would reduce it even more next time. Also had to leave it in the oven 15 mins as it wasn’t cooked. Im an amature baker but the taste and texture was perfect! Fab recipe, would recommend!
hi's picture
hi
28th May, 2018
5.05
Yes Never Tasted Millies cookies BUT I want some if this is how they taste. Really good. I ran out of caster at 60g so used 60 g more brown but didn't change the fact they were amazing
Craigus Fellerman's picture
Craigus Fellerman
11th Mar, 2018
5.05
These are fantastic I live abroad and miss Millies so much so was so happy when I tried these and they actually tasted like proper Millies cookies! I found after a few batches that I can easily get 20 from the amounts suggested, it also works well with gluten free self raising as tested and approved by a gluten free family member just takes 10 mins or so oh and keep them raised while baking and they come out perfect after 8-10 mins, I recommend using chunks of choc I used white they were amazing!!
Sassycook86
9th Mar, 2018
I love making these we chop up mars bars and them instead so good we've also used terrys choc orange white buttons and added peanut butter and choc chips best cookie recipe out there
Lisa Ismaili's picture
Lisa Ismaili
3rd Mar, 2018
5.05
Definitely the Best cookies I've ever made ! Easy to follow recipe that I will share with family and friends. Thanks for posting it.
Gingerjinks
3rd Mar, 2018
Made a batch of dough yesterday cooked off half and stored half for today! What a lovely sweet chewy cookie just like Millie's! My daughter has a nut allergy and can't risk eating store baked cookies so I was over the moon to be able to make these for her x the recipient is easy to follow. We used exact measurements but I used a little extra for on my hands to roll the dough into a sausage. We also put the dough in the refrigerator for 1hr before baking the first batch. I can see I'll be making this recipe a lot.
Lottie Pops's picture
Lottie Pops
17th Feb, 2018
I love making these but I switch it up and add coco and red food dye and the are amazing . Make them every week and I recommend making the to everyone to try out. No too sweet and not to crispy and leave until edges go brown and take them out and you bit and you get a crispy and soft texture at the same time ♥️
Lisa Ismaili's picture
Lisa Ismaili
3rd Mar, 2018
5.05
Hi how much cocoa and food dye do you add ? Thanks
Callum Kerr's picture
Callum Kerr
10th Feb, 2018
I made this but I doubled the recipe and got a really good bunch of cookies I made 20 and they were quite big I recommend this recipe to anyone it was really easy

Pages

Charlotte Dunn's picture
Charlotte Dunn
17th Jun, 2018
Can you add marshmallows to these cookies??
Lameesah Rahman's picture
Lameesah Rahman
21st Dec, 2017
Do you have to use light brown soft sugar, or can you use other types of sugar as a substitute?
Callum Kerr's picture
Callum Kerr
10th Feb, 2018
I completely forgot about brown sugar untill I read this but I never used it and it turned out great
megcat74
30th May, 2017
Hi can you freeze the cookie dough to cook later on?
shaunna13williams
7th Aug, 2017
I froze the dough into portion sized balls and cooked from frozen for warm fresh cookies each time, they were just as good as the first unfrozen batch I did.
megcat74
30th May, 2017
Can you make the dough and freeze it? Thanks.
Hannah_Eva_Mammy
5th Nov, 2016
5.05
Do I use salted or unsalted butter?? :o) xx
RedPanda02
17th Jun, 2017
I used unsalted as salt was added anyway and they came out beautifully , but I don't know if there would be a difference between using salted or unsalted
Ella-wella
17th Feb, 2016
5.05
Has anyone frozen the mix and if so, what was it as good as freshly made?
leahfluff
5th Aug, 2014
i just baked these cookies the middle of them is really, really greasy i think its the butter... what have i done wrong?

Pages

Gloria Joyanne's picture
Gloria Joyanne
4th May, 2018
3.8
This Recipe is so goodd however, the amount of sugar is too much. You guys can lessen the amount of sugar. Brown sugar: 75 gr Caster sugar: 110 gr
Raphy_ms
11th Mar, 2018
5.05
I absolutely love this recipe its so easy yet so tasty . Instead of light brown soft sugar I use demerara sugar I find it works great too. I also only use 100 grams of chocolate chips as 200 grams would be way too much!
Fiona Jones's picture
Fiona Jones
28th Jan, 2018
5.05
They were incredible. I used mixed white and dark chocolate chunks with 6 ferrero rocher i had left over- worked a treat!
rebecca phipps's picture
rebecca phipps
13th Jan, 2018
5.05
instead of 7mins cook for ten mins because when u cook for 7 mins its not properly cooked
Sara_M58's picture
Sara_M58
6th Jan, 2018
3.8
This was absolutely delicious but i think a tad bit too sweet so maybe you could make a little bit less sugar. Other than that it was amazing!
daniel625
9th Nov, 2017
5.05
Delicious! Very sweet. I used M&Ms instead of chocolate chips as I love a bit of colour. Make sure your butter is SOFT or the cookies won't spread enough (happened me on my first go). I'd also advise adding just a tiny bit more flour- about 10 grams extra, as some other commenters have said.
Louiehuckle's picture
Louiehuckle
17th Sep, 2017
Try adding raisins
Yui907's picture
Yui907
18th Feb, 2017
5.05
Recommend flattening your walnut sized balls into pancakes, as my first batch turned into cookie-balls.
Natasharrr
14th Jan, 2016
Amazing recipe !! Been trying to make biscuits for years this is the first that tastes great just like millies cookies my family loved them. The dough was too sticky to roll so I used a spoon to measure and place on the parchment paper. Tested 4 and took them out when still sticky in the middle underneath as they dry a bit when cooling down. GORGEOUS the sticky bit turned dry and chewy nom nom
zindzijade
26th Sep, 2015
These cookies were great. I followed some suggestions and added some vanilla essence and for a kick I added some coconut essence and shredded coconut too. That made them even tastier. I will have to reduce the sugar next time though because I found them a little too sweet.

Pages