Sticky toffee pudding with ice cream on blue plate

Sticky toffee pudding recipes

24 Recipes

See our most indulgent sticky toffee pudding recipes, perfect for Christmas. Try our vegan option for a new twist or go for one of our easy classics.

Gooey toffee puddings

5

(3 ratings)

Indulgent yet wonderfully light, these individual caramel sponges are baked with a sticky toffee sauce - keep in the freezer for a last-minute pud
  • 1 hour
  • Easy

Sticky toffee apple pudding

4.540375

(161 ratings)

Try a fruity version of the classic sticky toffee pudding for a rich after-dinner treat. Serve with cream, custard or vanilla ice cream
  • 1 hour
  • Easy

Sticky toffee pear pudding

4.76923

(13 ratings)

A lighter version of sticky toffee pudding, rich with dates and spices, and the juicy texture of poached pears, this vegan dessert is sure to please a crowd
  • 1 hour and 15 mins
  • More effort
  • Vegetarian

Sticky toffee parsnip pudding

4.57143

(7 ratings)

The parsnip makes the pudding extra light and soft – much like a carrot cake. Its earthy sweetness works wonderfully with the glossy caramel sauce...
  • 1 hour
  • Easy
  • Vegetarian

Lighter sticky toffee puddings

4.708335

(24 ratings)

This lighter version of a sticky toffee pudding is packed with sticky dates and uses maple syrup instead of sugar – serve it with a dollop of Greek yogurt...
  • 1 hour and 35 mins
  • More effort

Sticky toffee puddings

4.36842

(19 ratings)

MasterChef's Gregg Wallace shares his sumptuous recipe for the classic sticky toffee pudding
  • 45 mins
  • Easy

Sticky toffee tarts

3.5

(6 ratings)

This twist on classic sticky toffee pudding is ideal for a different dinner party dessert
  • 1 hour and 45 mins
  • More effort

Molten toffee puddings

5

(2 ratings)

If you love chocolate fondants, this sticky toffee version hides an irresistible melting centre - serve warm with ice cream
  • 40 mins
  • Easy

Sticky banoffee loaf with toffee sauce

3.857145

(7 ratings)

Bake a mash-up of sticky toffee pudding and banana loaf. Leftover cake will keep for a few days and is great with a cuppa – and the sauce is delicious with ice cream...
  • 1 hour
  • Easy
  • Vegetarian

Sticky date pudding with coconut caramel

5

(1 rating)

Try this luxurious version of sticky toffee pudding, using coconut milk for the caramel sauce. This is a pudding to share – friends will thank you for it!...
  • 1 hour
  • Easy
  • Vegetarian

Sticky date & raisin pudding

5

(4 ratings)

Keep everyone happy with this sticky toffee-like steamed basin pudding packed with dried fruit
  • 4 hours
  • More effort

Date & ginger malt loaf

4.7

(10 ratings)

A dark, sticky and lightly spiced cake that merges Jamaican ginger cake with sticky toffee pudding and malt loaf
  • 1 hour and 45 mins
  • Easy

Toffee apple squares

4.2

(5 ratings)

A crumble-like base, caramel nut topping and added juicy fruits - sticky toffee pud with a difference
  • 1 hour and 40 mins
  • More effort

Ginger treacle sponge

4.75

(4 ratings)

We know how you love hot treacle sponge and sticky ginger cake, so this gorgeous pud is sure to become a favourite
  • 2 hours and 15 mins
  • More effort

Pecan toffee cake

4.864405

(59 ratings)

Indulge in this gorgeously nutty cake for dessert, then serve the leftovers as you would Christmas cake to whoever pops by
  • 55 mins
  • Easy

Sticky pear & ginger cake

4.617645

(34 ratings)

This is a cross between a sticky toffee pudding and a ginger cake. Serve warm with ice cream or cream as a dessert
  • 2 hours and 30 mins
  • Easy

Rum & raisin puddings

4.285715

(7 ratings)

These individual desserts are deliciously naughty, so make plenty or you might have a fight on your hands when it comes to seconds
  • 1 hour and 25 mins
  • Easy

Festive date & pecan pudding

4.57143

(14 ratings)

Not your traditional Christmas pud, but a winner with our food team. A cross between sticky toffee and Christmas pud with a lighter feel
  • 1 hour and 55 mins
  • Easy
  • Vegetarian
Want to receive regular food and recipe web notifications from us?