Banoffee pie topped with cream frosting and bananas

Banoffee recipes

17 Recipes

Sink your spoon into our gooey, indulgent banoffee recipes. Banana and toffee flavours work together beautifully in banoffee pies, cakes, trifles and other desserts.

Next level banoffee pie


(3 ratings)

Take this classic dessert to the next level with our marvellous makeover, featuring salted caramel, banana chips, crushed biscuits and peanut butter cream
  • 1 hour and 5 mins
  • More effort
  • Vegetarian

Banoffee marshmallow cake


(34 ratings)

This fun cake won the 11-17 age group in our 20th birthday cake competition
  • 1 hour and 20 mins
  • Easy

Banoffee mess


(15 ratings)

A yummy toffee pudding that needs no cooking - it's a cross between banoffee pie and Eton mess
  • 10 mins
  • Easy

Sticky toffee banoffee cake


(40 ratings)

Sticky toffee banoffee, a variation on the classic Victoria sponge theme, perfect for birthdays and special occasion cakes
  • 30 mins
  • Easy

Mini banoffee pies


(14 ratings)

Go retro with this easy and ever-popular dessert that's been given a smart dinner party makeover...
  • 15 mins
  • Easy

Banoffee trifles


(6 ratings)

A trifle cheating will still impress your friends with this made-in-moments banoffee pud
  • 5 mins
  • Easy

Banoffee pie


(6 ratings)

An easy family favourite with buttery pastry and sweet dulce de leche. We recommend a generous dollop of cream to serve
  • 1 hour and 5 mins
  • Easy

Banoffee splits


(3 ratings)

A simple pudding with a creamy and indulgent Mars Bar sauce, ready in just 10 minutes
  • 10 mins
  • Easy

Grown-up banoffee pie


(11 ratings)

Lace this classic banana and toffee pie with a little dark rum. Top with whipped cream and chocolate
  • 1 hour and 50 mins
  • More effort

Sticky banoffee loaf with toffee sauce


(7 ratings)

Bake a mash-up of sticky toffee pudding and banana loaf. Leftover cake will keep for a few days and is great with a cuppa – and the sauce is delicious with ice cream...
  • 1 hour
  • Easy
  • Vegetarian

Banoffee s'mores


(2 ratings)

We love a classic American-style melty marshmallow s'more, so we created our own banana and toffee version with caramel sauce and chocolate oat biscuits
  • 5 mins
  • Easy
  • Vegetarian

Lighter banoffee pie


(4 ratings)

Angela Nilsen applies her magic touch to this classic banana and toffee dessert with shortcrust base and cream filling
  • 1 hour and 10 mins
  • Easy

Chocolate coconut banoffee pie


(12 ratings)

A dazzling dessert with bourbon biscuit base, caramel layer, creamy coconut topping and banana toffee
  • 1 hour and 30 mins
  • More effort

Butterscotch banana pie


(5 ratings)

This impressive looking salted caramel dessert is fit for a dinner party table, uses storecupboard ingredients and is ready in under half an hour
  • 25 mins
  • Easy
Want to receive regular food and recipe web notifications from us?