Critical conditions

Good Food Blog

What is RSS?

Posted at 11:42AM, 25 July 2008 by Graham Holliday - Blogger

Take one hyper-opinionated food writer, one sub-editor and a deleted indefinite article and what do you have? One enraged hyper-opinionated writer, a cowering sub-editor and an atomic email that lays waste to an entire editorial team.

Giles Coren, food critic for The Times, took umbrage when one small change was made to the final sentence of a review of his.

In his letter to the editorial team of The Times, he says: "I wrote: 'I can't think of a nicer place to sit this spring over a glass of rosé and watch the boys and girls in the street outside smiling gaily to each other, and wondering where to go for a nosh.'

It appeared as: 'I can't think of a nicer place to sit this spring over a glass of rosé and watch the boys and girls in the street outside smiling gaily to each other, and wondering where to go for nosh'."

Have food bloggers and Internet critics already taken over from the professional?

That's one of the few repeatable bits, the email goes on to deteriorate in spectacularly humourous fashion - if you're expletive intolerant tread carefully. In among Coren's steaming rant, his passion for food and for his work comes through - at ear splitting volume. But is it nothing more than the final squeal of a dying breed? Have food bloggers and Internet critics already taken over from the professional?

This is the question Jay Rayner asks on The Guardian Arts blog and in a long feature for The Observer. Rayner notes the death of the newspaper critic in the USA. "At least those of us in Britain who make our living from our opinions are still gainfully employed. Across America it's a different story. Paid newspaper critics from a number of disciplines are being laid off or redeployed, their judgment deemed superfluous to requirements in the age of the net."

He talks to bloggers and critics alike about the future of the professional critics. Some savvy newspapers are already handing over a lot of the traditional critic's work to expert bloggers and allowing for a free for all in the discussion sections of their websites. With sinking advertising revenues and decreased print sales, yet little in the way of online revenue, the first victims of the cashflow crisis will be the luxury items. And critics have always been a luxury.

There is a future for the very best professional food critics, but those that do manage to keep their jobs will have to learn they can't work in isolation anymore. The Internet is not a place to dictate opinion. It's an interactive and reactive medium and it's louder and more influential than a hundred hair pulling emails from Giles Coren.

Comments

Swedish Mike

25 July 2008, 12:43PM
Swedish Mike

I think that some of the critics are too far removed from what 'normal' people eat and think about food. See Michael Winner as an example. I'm not sure why The Times still publish his column? Is it just to wind people up perhaps? ;) // Mike

Flag as inappropriate

Please let us know your name and the reason you find the above comment inappropriate.

Your name: Reason:
Elaine

25 July 2008, 11:23PM
Elaine

Annoying though it is to have one's thoughtfully crafted words tweaked, this seems like a big over-reaction. He says he cares deeply about his work but this pompous, expletive-ridden rant was - dare I say it - in desperate need of subbing. Plus, sending offensive emails is rather cowardly. Simpler (and more grown-up) to pick up the phone and sort things out.

Flag as inappropriate

Please let us know your name and the reason you find the above comment inappropriate.

Your name: Reason:
Coffeebean

28 July 2008, 2:53PM
Coffeebean

I've never liked GC's reviews they are odiously conceited and he always comes across as being envious of AA Gill. I would be too, he hasn't an iota of Gill's writing talent and the way he attempts to jovially bring him into his columns time and again is clumsy and lacks any charm.

Flag as inappropriate

Please let us know your name and the reason you find the above comment inappropriate.

Your name: Reason:
StormyRaincloud

1 August 2008, 11:59AM
StormyRaincloud

Oh dear. While it must be annoying to have someone mess with your work, the only thing that came to mind while reading his childish rant was 'what a silly little boy' Sack him! Let's have some real talent take over who doesn't tantrum like a little boy.

Flag as inappropriate

Please let us know your name and the reason you find the above comment inappropriate.

Your name: Reason:
Frantic Flapjack

4 August 2008, 1:19PM
Frantic Flapjack

Having just read said email, I'm with you StormyRainCloud. Get rid of him.

Flag as inappropriate

Please let us know your name and the reason you find the above comment inappropriate.

Your name: Reason:

Your binder

Here are three other great reasons to sign up:

You get an online binder, where you can store all your favourite recipes and create menus.
You can add your own recipes to this site for others to try; plus, rate and make comments on recipes, and share your views on our blog.
You can sign up for our weekly newsletter (sent out on Wednesdays) - it's packed with recipes, special offers and competitions.